Page 48 - AEQUITAS VOL 2
P. 48

40



                                                                Case study 2: Intoxicated adult in disrupted
          Case Studies
                                                               position leading to positional asphyxia

         Case  study  1:  Positional  asphyxia
         without  active  restraint  following  an             A     26-year-old      male—intoxicated          with

         assault.                                              alcohol—was  discovered  deceased  in  an
                                                               unusual  and  restrictive  body  position  that

         Deaths due to positional asphyxia are                 interfered  with  his  ability  to  breathe
         most often accidental, associated with                normally. Although exact positioning details

         alcohol  and/or  drug  intoxication.  A               are not exhaustively described in the report,
         19-year-old  male  is  reported  to  have             it  is  clear  that  the  posture  was  inherently

         been assaulted and placed in a head-                  unsafe  and  led  directly  to  mechanical
         down  position  in  the  back  of  a  car,            impairment  of  his  pulmonary  ventilation.
         where he was later found dead. Brush                  Crucially,  no  external  signs  of  trauma  or

         abrasions indicated that he had been                  violence  were  observed,  underscoring  how
         dragged to the vehicle. The head and                  positional  asphyxia  can  occur  even  without

         right  shoulder  were  wedged  into  the              overt injury or restraint.
         foot  well  with  the  body  uppermost.

         At  autopsy,  there  was  marked                      SCENE DESCRIPTION
         congestion  of  the  face,  neck,  and                The      individual,      self-positioned       after

         upper      chest      with     conjunctival           consuming  alcohol,  due  to  intoxication,
         ecchymoses, bruising of the face and                  assumed a body posture that restricted chest
         scalp,         focal         subarachnoid             movement  and  airflow.  Scene  investigation

         hemorrhage,           minor         cerebral          revealed  there  were  no  signs  of  struggle  or
         contusion,      and     diffuse     cerebral          third-party  interference.  Death  was  clearly

         swelling  with  early  hypoxic  ischemic              noted as accidental. Posture was wedged or
         encephalopathy  (HIE).  Toxicology                    constrained;  the  report  does  not  include
         was negative. Death was attributed to                 photographs.

         HIE  resulting  from  the  unusual
         positioning  of  the  body.  Cases  of                AUTOPSY FINDINGS

         positional  asphyxia  involving  others                    External  examination:  no  external
         may not always include restraint, and                      injuries  or  significant  marks  were

         when  encountered,  should  initiate  a                    seen(e.g.  abrasions,  bruises  or  ligature
         careful  evaluation  of  the  possible                     marks)

         events  and  lethal  pathophysiological                    Internal  examination:  the  conclusion
         processes.                                                 states  that  the  diagnosis  is  based  solely
                                                                    on  the  disruptive  body  posture  in  an
                                                                    intoxicated individual.
   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53